Go to Home Page
Main Message Board | Treatment Discussions | Polls | MC FAQs | Recipes | Information Sites | Medication Info | Diet Info | Jokes | Photo Gallery
  Username:    Password:      Remember me       
MICROSCOPIC COLITIS SUPPORT Forum Index

You can get your life back
MICROSCOPIC COLITIS SUPPORT
Discussion and Support Forum for Collagenous Colitis, Lymphocytic Colitis, Microscopic Colitis, Mastocytic Enterocolitis, and Related Issues

MICROSCOPIC COLITIS SUPPORT Forum IndexVisit the Microscopic Colitis Foundation Website
 

The only comprehensive book ever written about Microscopic Colitis
Can be ordered at any bookstore or library
 FAQFAQ  RulesRules   SearchSearch   MemberlistMemberlist   UsergroupsUsergroups  ChatChat   RegisterRegister 
 ProfileProfile   Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages   Log inLog in 
 World Time Clock--Time ZonesPotty People T-ShirtsPrivacy Policy
Google
SearchSearch The Archives of This Discussion Board
What Do Y'all Think of This?

 
Post new topic   Reply to topic       MICROSCOPIC COLITIS SUPPORT Forum Index -> Discussions About MRT Testing
 View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
MBombardier
Rockhopper Penguin
Rockhopper Penguin


Joined: 14 Oct 2010

Posts: 1524
User's local time:
2017 Aug 18 - 5:33 PM


Food Intolerances : Grains, dairy, legumes (especially soy), and eggs. Avoiding nightshades, cruciferous veggies, and high-histamine foods.
Location: Vancouver, WA

PostPosted: Mon Aug 08, 2011 9:54 pm    Post subject: What Do Y'all Think of This? Reply with quote

http://www.scdkat.com

I am trying to clear out my Google Reader, and I ran across this woman's story of her ELISA testing. What do you think of what she says and what her naturopath said?

Quote:
If you have Celiac disease, the damage done to the intestines leaves you with intestinal permiability. This means you need to be aware that other foods are probably causing you problems and will continue to do so until you heal the intestinal tract. I would argue that most people with gastrointestinal symptoms have some degree of leaky gut syndrome. A food allergy test in my opinion is useless except to tell you that you do in fact have leaky gut. It would probably tell you that you’re allergic to everything you’re eating.

Most Naturopaths will tell you to avoid all foods you test high or moderate for, seeing the test as a final result. Do this and take the blood test again in a few months, and I wouldn’t be surprised if your results are different, showing a higher reaction to the new foods you are eating. My naturopath reacted a little differently. She didn’t tell me to cut anything out, but did introduce me to the concept of rotation diet. Foods that I was reacting to at a high level I would not eat every single day, but once every few days. That made sense to me and helped me get a bit more variety in my diet. Especially with meats which at the time I was just eating beef, chicken and pork. I started eating lamb, duck, turkey and various game meats. I also started trying to get seafood once a week. I had a hard time with vegetables and was scared of raw fruit at the time, so I didn’t manage to get much variety there but I did rotate through the ones I was eating.


She goes on to say that she eventually healed with out removing any of the foods that were on her "high" list.

Reading this made me realize that I have been wondering about this myself because of my own allergic peculiarities. Sometimes I am allergic to some foods (like watermelon, cherries, dates, almonds, others) and sometimes not. When I was a teenager, I was allergic to apples for a few years, then decided that "an apple a day keeps the doctor away" and started eating them anyway. Within a short time I was no longer allergic to them, and have not been allergic to them since.

Even in my own health, though, there seems to be two sides to this. I became desensitized to apples by eating more of them, but I became allergic to cats and dogs after living with them for many years.

But getting back to the food thing... what do you think of Kat's experience? Can rotating foods (as many on the forum do) be perhaps the first, possibly best route to remission?
_________________
Marliss Bombardier

Dum spiro, spero -- While I breathe, I hope

Psoriasis - the dark ages
Hashimoto's Thyroiditis - Dec 2001
Collagenous Colitis - Sept 2010
Granuloma Annulare - June 2011
Back to top
tex
Site Admin
Site Admin


Joined: 24 May 2005

Posts: 30278
User's local time:
2017 Aug 18 - 7:33 PM


Food Intolerances : Gluten, casein, soy, and avenin, (avenin is the prolamin in oats, which is equivalent to the gluten in wheat), beef, grapes, peanuts, cashews, almonds, (but nut butters seem OK except for peanuts), citric acid, chocolate, and agar.
Location: Central Texas

PostPosted: Tue Aug 09, 2011 8:04 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
Do this and take the blood test again in a few months, and I wouldn’t be surprised if your results are different,


She wouldn't be surprised? This is the best argument that she can come up with? No epidemiological evidence, other than her own case? That's kind of skimpy evidence.

Marliss wrote:
But getting back to the food thing... what do you think of Kat's experience? Can rotating foods (as many on the forum do) be perhaps the first, possibly best route to remission?


shrug If you read my reports on my oat challenge, you know that it certainly didn't work for me. Unlike her, though, I don't claim that means that it can't work for anyone. The difference, of course, is that I'm actually sensitive to oats, and she's not really sensitive to the foods that she claims to have been sensitive to, or she wouldn't have been able to eat them and achieve remission of symptoms.

Why would someone continue to eat something, if it made them sick. If it didn't make her sick, by rotating it, then she obviously wasn't really sensitive to it. It's as simple as that, IMO.

She apparently wasn't having any symptoms, (if she was, she didn't mention them) - she was simply rotating foods because of the blood test results. My thoughts on that are that trying to modify one's diet based on worthless test results is a lost cause, because the whole program is confounded right off the bat.

The main point here, though, is the fact that she had an "allergy" test done on a blood sample - not stool tests. So I agree with her - an IgG blood test is absolutely worthless for determining the effects of foods on the digestive system. She never revealed why she was doing the SCD in the first place, did she? I'm just assuming that she did it, (together with the food rotation program), to prove the blood test wrong, but maybe I'm jumping to the wrong conclusion, here. shrug

She writes as if she were an authority on the topic, and yet, if you scroll down and read her comments about vitamin D, for example, she doesn't even consider it to be a factor. Say what? She considers cod liver oil to be a valid source of vitamin D. Rolling Eyes In fact, cod liver oil is a good way to destroy the benefits of vitamin D, because of the extremely high vitamin A level, (high levels of vitamin A almost completely negate the benefits of vitamin D, according to research). There are much better ways to get vitamin D.

So, my opinion is, she almost surely has good intentions, but she doesn't really understand what she's talking about. That's just my opinion, of course, based on what I read in portions of her blog. Presumably, some of what she says has some value, such as pointing out that the blood tests for food sensitivities based on IgG antibodies, are totally worthless. The problem that I have with her blog, is that she infers that what she says applies to all food testing, (the title is "Food Allergy Testing"), when in fact, she only has experience with a single, irrelevant test, (IgG blood testing). And, as we all know, food allergies are not the primary concern with food-sensitivities for most of us with MC - we're more concerned about autoimmune reactions, and that's a completely different issue.

shrug . . . . just my opinion, FWIW. Remember, food allergies, and the type of food sensitivities in the digestive system that we have to deal with due to MC, are almost totally unrelated. Also, remember that the IgG test that she had is not based on mediator response testing, (MRT).

Tex
_________________
cowboy

It is suspected that some of the hardest material known to science can be found in the skulls of GI specialists who insist that diet has nothing to do with the treatment of microscopic colitis.
Back to top
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic      Reply to topic    MICROSCOPIC COLITIS SUPPORT Forum Index -> Discussions About MRT Testing All times are GMT - 6 Hours
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum

Remove cookies set by this forum

Search online dictionaries
(Powered by OneLook® Dictionary Search)
Enter word or phrase:
Enter a word to search for dictionary web sites that include that word.
Enter a pattern consisting of letters and wildcards to search for words.
Valid wildcards are * (matches multiple letters) and ? (matches one letter).
Locations of visitors to this page


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
IP Country Flag 2.9.6b © 2005, 2008 - 3Di (aka 3D)

Copyright © 2005–2017 perskyfarms.com, All Rights Reserved

Copyright Notice: The material on this site is copyrighted by perskyfarms.com, and it is protected from unauthorized copying and dissemination by United States copyright law, trademark law, international conventions, and other intellectual property laws. This copyright protection also extends to any and all images, found on any and all pages of this site.

Please contact us at this address for permission, if you wish to use any material on this website for any commercial or public purpose.

We have made a good faith effort not to violate any copyright. If we have unknowingly done so, please contact the site administrator, at this address, and the issue will be promptly corrected.

Disclaimer: The information contained within this site is intended solely for general educational purposes, and is not intended, nor implied, to be a substitute for professional medical advice relative to your specific medical condition or question. Anyone who chooses to use any information found here, does so at his or her own risk. Always seek the advice of your physician or other health care provider for any questions you may have regarding your medical condition. Only your physician can provide specific diagnoses and therapies. By using this site you agree to the following terms and conditions:

Certain members of this discussion board are practicing medical professionals. They are not here to offer medial advice, they are here because they have been diagnosed with microsopic colitis, and they are interested in sharing their own personal experiences concerning the disease, and learning from others in all walks of life, who also have to deal with these issues. If you have any questions or concerns regarding your health, you should consult with your own doctor, or medial professional.

If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor, or 911, immediately. The members of this board, regardless of whether or not they are medical professionals, cannot respond to issues requiring urgent medical attention. Please note that no legal action can be taken by any user of this site, as a result of any information found here, and that none of the parties involved, neither individually, nor collectively, nor the owner of this site, can be held responsible for any information offered in the course of discussions, regardless of circumstances, whether those discussions are in a public or private form, and regardless of whether of not any of the parties involved are professionals. Remember that this discussion board is not intended to be a replacement for a consultation with your doctor or other medical professonal, it is intended as a sharing of knowledge and information from the research and personal experience of the members of this discussion board.

This site does not recommend or endorse any specific tests, products, procedures, opinions, or other information that may be mentioned anywhere on this site. Reliance on any information provided here is solely at your own risk.

Main Message Board | Treatment Discussions | Polls | MC FAQs | Recipes | Information Sites | Medication Info | Diet Info | Jokes | Photo Gallery